News · Chattanooga
Chattanooga’s Nippon Paint clawback would bring back $1.1 million and 10 acres, and let the company off its $60 million, 150-job promise
CHATTANOOGA — Mayor Tim Kelly’s administration wants to settle with Nippon Paint over the factory the company promised to build on city-donated land in East Chattanooga, and the deal on the table would return about $1.1 million and 10 acres to taxpayers while releasing the company from its larger promises. The City Council is set to vote Nov. 3.
The proposal ran into skepticism Tuesday at the council’s economic development committee. “I will not be supporting this deal. It is very weak, and it’s not strong enough,” council member Dennis Clark said, according to the Chattanooga Times Free Press.
What the city gave. In 2019 the city donated about 29 acres at the former Harriet Tubman public housing site to Nippon Paint Automotive Americas. Chattanoogan.com reported the city also spent about $4 million to move a sewer line and built the Hardy Street extension to serve the property. A city spokesperson said the sewer work was finished ahead of its deadline in August 2020.
What Nippon promised, and what it built. The company agreed to $60 million in capital investment and 150 new jobs averaging about $47,000 a year by Dec. 31, 2027. Charita Allen, the city’s senior advisor for economic and workforce development, told the committee Nippon has invested about $52 million and employs 30 to 35 people, 32 at last count. Only one of three planned buildings went up. “They never reached full production, which is why the jobs that they had committed for the community, those phase two and three jobs never happened,” Allen said.
What the settlement does. Nippon would pay about $1.1 million, which Chattanoogan.com put at $1,057,600, the land’s original appraised value, and give back 10 undeveloped acres. Both sides would release the remaining claims, including the investment and jobs targets. The city keeps collecting property taxes on the existing plant. The resolution is on the proposed Nov. 3 agenda as a settlement “to exercise clawback and settlement provisions derived from the Donation Agreement.”
Council member Ron Elliott wanted a harder line: “Why don’t we snatch all the land back and make them lease it?” Kevin Roig, Kelly’s chief of staff, answered, “We’re going to exercise whatever recourse that we have, but I don’t think that we want to be overly punitive.” Allen said negotiations are not finished.
Our take. Clawbacks exist so taxpayers are not left holding the bag when an incentive deal underdelivers. By our math, Nippon came within about $8 million of its investment pledge but delivered roughly a fifth of the promised jobs, and jobs were the point of giving away public land. Getting back the land’s value plus a third of the acreage is better than nothing, but council members are right to ask whether the city should accept a full release more than a year before the 2027 deadline. A cleaner test before Nov. 3: what would the returned 10 acres be worth today, and what would the city collect if it waited out the deadline?
Neighbors have their own grievance. Eric Atkins, co-chair of the Unity Group of Chattanooga, said residents pushed for housing, local hiring and a community benefits agreement that never came. “It’s the greatest missed opportunity of my lifetime, and of the lifetime of this community,” he told the Times Free Press.
The council’s Nov. 3 meeting is set for 3:30 p.m., according to the proposed agenda.
Sources:
Chattanooga Times Free Press, “City Council debates settlement to ‘clawback’ Nippon Paint investment,” Oct. 27, 2026 (settlement terms, investment and jobs figures, Clark, Allen, Elliott, Roig and Atkins quotes), https://www.timesfreepress.com/news/2026/oct/27/city-council-debates-settlement-to-clawback/
Chattanoogan.com, “City Seeking ‘Clawback’ From Nippon Paint On Stalled East Chattanooga Project,” Oct. 27, 2026 (payment amount, sewer relocation and Hardy Street extension), https://www.chattanoogan.com/2026/10/27/525299/City-Seeking-Clawback-From-Nippon.aspx
City of Chattanooga, proposed City Council agenda for Nov. 3, 2026 (settlement resolution), https://register.chattanooga.gov/sites/default/files/resources/10-27-2026-Council-Agenda_0.pdf
Photo: Andrew Jameson, “MunicipalBuildingChattanooga.jpg,” April 16, 2010, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/), cropped and color-adjusted, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:MunicipalBuildingChattanooga.jpg
