News · Clarksville
Clarksville pain clinic managers will pay $1.5 million, with no finding of liability
CLARKSVILLE — Two companies that ran a Clarksville pain clinic, and two managers, have agreed to pay the United States $1.5 million over allegations they billed Medicare and the Department of Veterans Affairs for tests patients did not need. U.S. Attorney Braden H. Boucek announced the settlement for the Middle District of Tennessee. The government says the claims are allegations only. There has been no determination of liability.
The named parties are Clarksville Pain Institute, LLC; Pain Institute of Nashville, PLC; Michael Cox; and Debbie Cox. A complaint the United States filed on Sept. 11, 2024, alleges they submitted, or caused others to submit, false claims for urine drug testing, allergy testing, and psychological testing between April 2014 and May 2024. Clarksville Now and WZTV both quote the release. The clinic’s main site was in Clarksville, in Montgomery County, with other offices in White House and Springfield. It merged with Pain Institute of Nashville in 2018. Michael Cox and Debbie Cox held management jobs at both. Debbie Cox also held an ownership interest in both.
“Federal health care programs exist to provide necessary medical care, not to generate payments for unnecessary testing,” Boucek said in the release. “When providers allegedly misuse these programs for financial gain, they undermine public trust and divert taxpayer dollars from legitimate patient care.” The “allegedly” is the government’s word. The settlement does not include an admission that any named test was unnecessary.
A former employee’s share is $285,000
The deal also ends a whistleblower lawsuit filed by Krista Nicholson, a former employee, under the False Claims Act’s qui tam rules. Those rules let a private person sue in the government’s name and take a share of what is recovered. Nicholson’s share is $285,000 of the $1.5 million. The rest goes to the United States. The release does not say how the $1.5 million is split between Medicare and the VA, or between the two companies and the two managers. It says they pay collectively.
The investigation was the U.S. Attorney’s Office, the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General, and the VA’s inspector general. Assistant U.S. Attorney Wynn M. Shuford represented the United States. Premier Medical Group, a different Clarksville practice, agreed this month to pay $2.8 million to settle separate claims about Medicare and TRICARE billing under doctors’ identification numbers. The pain-clinic payment is not that case, and the dollar figures should not be added together.
What a settlement is, and what it is not
A False Claims settlement of this kind buys an end to the civil allegations. It is not a criminal conviction, and the release does not name a doctor, a patient, or a single test result. The decade in the complaint, April 2014 through May 2024, is the period the government says the bills cover. It is not a finding that every test in those years was improper. Readers who were patients at the Clarksville office, or at the White House or Springfield offices, do not get a refund from this announcement. The money goes to the federal government and to Nicholson.
The photograph is downtown Clarksville. It does not show the clinic, and it does not show a courtroom where a judge weighed the allegations. Those allegations remain unresolved as facts, even though the payment is agreed.
Sources:
Clarksville Now, Christian Brown, “Clarksville clinic agrees to pay $1.5M to resolve allegations involving medically unnecessary testing,” Nov. 13, 2026, quoting the U.S. Attorney’s Office release, https://clarksvillenow.com/local/clarksville-clinic-agrees-to-pay-1-5m-to-resolve-allegations-involving-medically-unnecessary-testing/
WZTV, Ashley Griffin, “Clarksville pain clinic operators agree to $1.5 million federal settlement,” Nov. 13, 2026, https://fox17.com/news/local/clarksville-pain-clinic-operators-agree-to-15-million-federal-settlement
Photo: GatewayPolitics, “Downtown Clarksville TN.jpg”, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3ADowntown_Clarksville_TN.jpg
