News · Cookeville
Cookeville council votes Thursday on buying the AmeriGas lot at 80 Depot St. for $555,000 to carry Oak Avenue across the tracks
COOKEVILLE — The Cookeville City Council will vote Thursday, Nov. 5, on spending $555,000 for a piece of land the city says it cannot do without: the AmeriGas property at 80 Depot St., which stands in the way of carrying Oak Avenue across the railroad tracks as part of the 39 Depot project.
City Manager James Mills told the council the city needs the 1.15-acre lot, about 50,000 square feet, to make the Oak Avenue connection, UC Now reported.
“We have to have this property,” Mills said. “I’d like to go ahead and get your authorization to finalize this and sign it, and then we’ll still be several weeks away from actually closing on it.”
The price
Mills said the city negotiated at length with AmeriGas and that the $555,000 price is nearly $275,000 below an earlier counteroffer from the company.
“I don’t think we could have got a better deal than what we got,” he said. “And again, it still blows my mind what property costs, but it is what it is.”
By our math, the price works out to about $483,000 an acre, or roughly $11 a square foot.
Part of the problem, Mills said, is that the city set its own benchmark. Recent city purchases across the street served as comparable values in the talks, which made it harder to argue for a lower number. “We leveraged everything we could,” he said. “Part of our issue here is we’ve set our own cost comparisons by the property we bought just across the street from us, so it was kind of getting kind of hard to argue on this purchase price.”
What Thursday’s vote does
The city and AmeriGas are still finishing the purchase-and-sale agreement. Thursday’s vote would let Mills sign it and buy the property without waiting for another council meeting, according to UC Now.
Buying the land would also open the way for more engineering on 39 Depot. Mills said he expects to bring an amended engineering agreement with the firm ASA to the council as early as its next meeting, covering at least phases two and three of the project and folding the AmeriGas property into the design.
Thursday’s meeting is open to the public. All times are Central.
Sources:
UC Now, “Cookeville Negotiates Land Acquisition For 39 Depot” (Nov. 2, 2026; property, price, Mills quotes, council action, engineering agreement), https://theucnow.com/2026/11/02/cookeville-negotiates-land-acquisition-for-39-depot/
Photo: Brian Stansberry, “Cookeville-west-side-depot-tn-1.jpg,” Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0), https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cookeville-west-side-depot-tn-1.jpg
