Election 2026 · Franklin
5th District forum in Spring Hill: Republican Charlie Hatcher calls tariffs “a tool in the toolbox,” Democrat Chaz Molder wants them gone, and no debate is on the calendar
SPRING HILL — The two major-party candidates for Tennessee’s redrawn 5th Congressional District shared a stage Wednesday night in Spring Hill, likely for the last time before the Nov. 3 election, and the sharpest split between them was over President Donald Trump’s tariffs.
Republican Charlie Hatcher, a dairy farmer and former Tennessee agriculture commissioner, and Democrat Chaz Molder, the mayor of Columbia since 2018, both named the cost of living as their first priority. Independent Micheál O’Leary, an Irish-born businessman and former local official in California, also took part. A fourth candidate, independent James Johnson, is on the ballot but did not attend, News Channel 5 reported. The forum was hosted by the Spring Hill, Maury County and Williamson County chambers of commerce.
Tariffs. Hatcher called tariffs a tool that “can be used effectively, sometimes badly,” and said farmers are the first to feel them. He pointed to tariffs on Canadian dairy and imported Chinese steel as examples of using them to protect American producers. “We need to support American industries, and we need to support American agriculture so that we can … not have other countries hold us hostage,” he said, according to the Tennessee Lookout. Asked afterward whether he objected to the president setting tariffs without Congress, Hatcher told reporters that farm trade is “better than it was during the Biden administration by a long shot” and that tariffs have “been used very effectively in many cases,” the Nashville Banner reported.
Molder said removing tariffs is one of his top priorities. “They are wrong, and they are at the wrong time,” he said, arguing that they raise prices when people are hurting and that Congress has given up its role in setting them. Hatcher called that argument “talking points.”
Prices, energy and the war. Both men said ending the war in Iran would bring down fuel prices. Hatcher said it should end once two conditions are met: Iran has no nuclear weapons and cannot hold “a stranglehold on the global oil market.” His longer-term answer is to “unleash American energy,” with more refineries and more nuclear power. He defended the One Big Beautiful Bill’s tax breaks on tips and overtime, told reporters he would have voted for it, and said that in Congress he would be “more of a fiscal hawk.”
Border and ICE. Molder said the border is “more secure today” than before Trump took office, but called for a congressional investigation of Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Hatcher said ICE went too far in some instances, naming Minnesota, but has “backed off since,” and said he would not support an investigation. On the Memphis Safe Task Force, Hatcher said local leaders want it in place for now; Molder said his first call in office would be to the Justice Department about it.
Growth. Hatcher said infrastructure money should go first to projects that serve the most people, and he would leave data center decisions to local governments. Molder said Columbia used impact fees so “growth can pay for growth” instead of current residents.
No debate. Both candidates had said they wanted a debate. Hatcher said the forum, with questions shared in advance, was enough: “We’ve got 13 days left, and every minute’s accounted for.” Molder said it would be “a huge disappointment” if none is scheduled.
What’s at stake. The district was redrawn in May by the Republican-led legislature. It no longer includes Nashville and now runs from Williamson and Maury counties through rural West Tennessee into part of Memphis. Molder’s run left Columbia’s mayor’s seat open, as we reported Oct. 18; Williamson County’s state House races are in our Oct. 19 rundown.
How to vote. The registration deadline for this election passed Oct. 5. Early voting runs through Thursday, Oct. 29; hours and sites are set by each county election commission. Oct. 24 is the deadline to request an absentee ballot, and Tennessee requires an eligible reason to vote absentee, such as being 60 or older. On Election Day, Tuesday, Nov. 3, vote at your assigned polling place and bring a federal or Tennessee government-issued photo ID; college student IDs are not accepted. Polls close at 7 p.m. Central and 8 p.m. Eastern. County election commissions certify results by Monday, Nov. 23. Look up your polling place and sample ballot at GoVoteTN.gov.
Sources:
Tennessee Lookout, “District 5 Congressional candidates Molder, Hatcher clash over tariffs in forum,” Oct. 23, 2026, https://tennesseelookout.com/2026/10/23/district-5-congressional-candidates-molder-hatcher-clash-over-tariffs-in-forum/
Nashville Banner, “Here’s What Congressional Candidates Charlie Hatcher and Chaz Molder Told Reporters After Joint Appearance,” Oct. 23, 2026, https://nashvillebanner.com/2026/10/23/tennessee-fifth-district-candidates-forum-folo/
News Channel 5 Nashville, “Three candidates lay out priorities for Tennessee’s 5th Congressional District at public forum,” https://www.newschannel5.com/news/three-candidates-lay-out-priorities-for-tennessees-5th-congressional-district-at-public-forum
Photo: Skye Marthaler, “Spring Hill City Hall.JPG,” Dec. 28, 2013, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/), cropped and resized, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Spring_Hill_City_Hall.JPG
