News · Jackson
Jackson council names Caroline Ballentine city court judge after Mayor Conger says a Sunshine Law violation came first
JACKSON — The Jackson City Council on Tuesday named assistant public defender Caroline Ballentine the city’s next city court judge, after several rounds of voting and an accusation from one councilman that led Mayor Scott Conger to say a Sunshine Law violation had happened before the meeting, WBBJ reported.
Ballentine was picked from the applicants who sat for open public interviews before the council on Oct. 27. The others were Jackson attorney J. Colin Morris, attorney and former circuit court judge Nathan Pride, and family and civil defense attorney Kortney Simmons, WBBJ reported. Former Madison County General Sessions Judge J. Mark Patey withdrew his application on Nov. 2. WBBJ had reported that the Board of Judicial Conduct suspended Patey in April, which raised questions about his eligibility.
Conger said ahead of the vote that the council had set up a special runoff process in which a candidate needed five votes to win, Raw 100.5 reported.
“I wanted to be city court judge to make a difference and make a lasting impression here in Jackson and also to follow in Judge Anderson’s footsteps,” Ballentine said after the vote.
What was said before the vote
District 1 Councilman J.P. Stovall told the council that before the meeting, two council members approached him and mentioned a certain person’s voting record. “I think it is absolutely disgraceful,” he said. When District 4 Councilman Richard Donnell asked who they were, Stovall named Councilman Lowrance and Councilwoman Busby, WBBJ reported.
“It needs to be said. It was a Sunshine violation,” Conger said. WBBJ’s report did not include a response from Lowrance or Busby, and none had been reported when this story was published.
Tennessee’s Open Meetings Act, often called the Sunshine Law, requires governing bodies to deliberate and decide public business in open meetings. It says chance meetings or informal gatherings of members may not be used to deliberate or decide public business to get around that requirement, and it allows courts to void actions taken in violation of the act. A mayor’s statement at a meeting is not a legal finding, and no complaint or lawsuit over Tuesday’s vote had been reported.
The audit and other spending
Conger was also asked when the city’s overdue 2025 audit will be finished. “We turned over everything. It is moving very quickly now. I think we should have it back by start or mid December,” he said.
The council approved two road matches: $400,000 for Airways Boulevard and $150,000 for an Interstate 40 westbound ramp. It also took up a contract with Flock Safety for gunshot detection technology for the Jackson Police Department, WBBJ reported. Conger said the city’s Flock license plate cameras sit on arterial and collector streets, though WBBJ noted several are in residential areas, including one on Old Malesus Road.
Sources:
WBBJ, “Jackson mayor says Sunshine violation occurred before council appoints city court judge” (Nov. 4, 2026; Stovall and Conger quotes, Ballentine quote, audit, road matches, Flock), https://www.wbbjtv.com/2026/11/04/jackson-mayor-says-sunshine-violation-occurred-before-council-appoints-city-court-judge/
WBBJ, “Jackson City Council appoints new city court judge” (Nov. 3, 2026; Ballentine, other applicants, Patey withdrawal), https://www.wbbjtv.com/2026/11/03/jackson-city-council-appoints-new-city-court-judge/
Raw 100.5, “Jackson City Council to choose a city judge Tuesday from four remaining applicants” (five-vote runoff process), https://raw1005.com/story/jackson-city-council-to-choose-a-city-judge-tuesday-from-fou-15bb3b/
WBBJ, “Jackson council interviews city court judge candidates, vote set for Nov. 3” (Oct. 27, 2026; public interviews, Patey suspension), https://www.wbbjtv.com/2026/10/27/jackson-council-interviews-city-court-judge-candidates-vote-set-nov-3/
Tennessee Open Meetings Act, Tenn. Code Ann. §§ 8-44-101 to 8-44-111 (chance meetings and voiding provisions)
Photo: Jerrye and Roy Klotz, M.D., “EAST MAIN STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT, JACKSON, MADISON COUNTY, TN.jpg,” Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0), https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:EAST_MAIN_STREET_HISTORIC_DISTRICT,_JACKSON,_MADISON_COUNTY,_TN.jpg
