News · Kingsport
Sullivan County shelves a ‘trigger’ ban on license plate cameras until April as Republican commissioners split over privacy and policing
BLOUNTVILLE, Tenn. — Sullivan County’s fight over license plate reader cameras will carry into next year. At its Thursday, Oct. 15, meeting, the county commission saw one anti-Flock resolution withdrawn and tabled a second, a “trigger” ban on the cameras, until its April 2027 meeting, the Kingsport Times News and the Bristol Herald Courier reported.
Commissioner Joe Carr of Kingsport withdrew Resolution No. 3, which would have barred the county and all of its departments from funding, participating in or accessing “warrantless municipal ALPR data.” “Unfortunately, I do not have enough support for it,” Carr said, according to the Times News. He noted that the sheriff’s office “can just go ahead and call up Kingsport or Bristol” for data from Kingsport’s Flock Safety cameras or Bristol’s Motorola plate readers. Johnson City also uses Flock cameras, the paper reported.
The second measure, Resolution No. 4, co-sponsored by Commissioner Lakie Derrick of Kingsport, would ban automated license plate readers “by all entities, public or private” in Sullivan County, but only if the state legislature or Congress gives the county that power. Commissioner Matthew Johnson moved to table it until April, and Carr accepted the motion, which ended the discussion, the papers reported. The Times News reported that the motion noted ALPR bills would already be filed in the legislature by then.
Carr made it a constitutional argument aimed at his own party. “If we can’t conserve the Constitution, what are we conserving?” he asked. All 24 commissioners identify as Republicans, the Times News reported, though Commissioner Zac Thomas of Kingsport ran as an independent. Derrick called the cameras a Fourth Amendment issue and said residents overwhelmingly do not want them. “This should not be a difficult thing to get behind,” she said.
Carr also questioned the cameras’ accuracy. He said Flock officials have put the rate of completely correct plate reads at 93%, and he pointed to a reported stop in Morristown in which officers with guns drawn pulled over two grandparents taking their grandchild to the doctor after a camera could not tell a zero from the letter O, according to the Times News.
Other commissioners were not ready to go that far. David Akard of Bristol and Mark Ireson of Colonial Heights said they could not support the trigger resolution, with Ireson saying it might leave the county following a camera mandate its leaders opposed. “We’re three weeks away from maybe having a Democratic governor in Tennessee. I can’t support it,” Ireson said. New Commissioner Don Thompson said he supports “guardrails and guidelines” from the state and federal governments but that the time to discuss them is next spring and summer. He also said it would be unconstitutional to bar city police from using the technology and questioned how businesses could be kept from using cameras on their own property.
The vote is the latest turn in a fight that has run all year. Sheriff Jeff Cassidy earlier agreed to turn off law enforcement access to 10 county cameras that cost more than $30,000 a year after a heated commission meeting, the Times News reported, and the commission later voted unanimously not to renew the county’s Flock contract, Tennessee Conservative News reported. Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti has said the cameras are likely legal under certain circumstances but acknowledged the technology can be abused, according to that outlet. Former Commissioner Gary Stidham of Kingsport, the only candidate for the District 2 state House seat, has said the General Assembly will likely put “guard rails” on Flock-type cameras next year.
In other business Thursday, Carr also withdrew a request for one-time funding of $50,000 for Petworks, a Kingsport nonprofit animal services group, saying it did not have enough support, the Times News reported.
Sources:
Rick Wagner, “One anti-Flock Sullivan resolution withdrawn, other tabled until April,” Kingsport Times News, Oct. 15, 2026, https://timesnews.net/news/416611/one-anti-flock-sullivan-resolution-withdrawn-other-tables-until-april/
Robert Sorrell, “Sullivan commissioners delay one Flock camera resolution, withdraw another,” Bristol Herald Courier, Oct. 17, 2026, https://heraldcourier.com/news/local/government-politics/article_bfb8840b-2334-4519-94ea-5f2031bc9b29.html
Olivia Lupia, “Sullivan County Commission To Consider More Anti-ALPR Proposals,” Tennessee Conservative News, Oct. 15, 2026, https://tennesseeconservativenews.com/sullivan-county-commission-to-consider-more-anti-alpr-proposals/
Tennessee Conservative News, “Anti-Flock Sullivan County Commissioners Propose First-Of-Its-Kind Camera Ban,” https://tennesseeconservativenews.com/anti-flock-sullivan-county-commissioners-propose-first-of-its-kind-camera-ban/
Image: Tony Webster, “Flock Safety ALPR Camera (Automated License Plate Reader),” Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Flock_Safety_ALPR_Camera_(Automated_License_Plate_Reader)_(54490802773).jpg
