News · Maryville
Blount County jury gives Johnny Ray Wilburn life without parole for killing three members of the Farley family and setting their Walland home on fire
MARYVILLE — A Blount County jury on Tuesday sentenced Johnny Ray Wilburn to life in prison without the possibility of parole for killing three members of a Walland family and setting their home on fire in January 2025.
Jurors found Wilburn guilty on 38 of the 39 counts against him, including first-degree murder, WBIR and WIVK reported. He was acquitted on one count of aggravated animal abuse. The jury received the case around 10:15 a.m. Tuesday and returned its verdict that afternoon, then decided the murder sentence. Judge David Duggan revoked Wilburn’s bond and set sentencing on the remaining convictions for Jan. 7.
The victims. Cas Ivan Farley, 61, Delmar “Marty” Farley, 59, and Norma Kaye Farley, 65, lived on Payne Hollow Road in Walland. Firefighters found their bodies on Jan. 19, 2025, in the debris of the house fire they had just put out, according to court records cited by WBIR. Wilburn knew all three: Kay Farley was his former stepmother, and witnesses testified that he had once lived with the family. Relatives described the Farleys as people who would “give you the shirt off their back,” WIVK reported.
What prosecutors argued. District Attorney General Ryan Desmond and prosecutors Tyler Parks and Tegan Couch told jurors Wilburn killed the Farleys because he was short on cash. “To Johnny Wilburn, that man, what were those three lives worth? $400 for three guns? Are you kidding me?” Desmond said in closing arguments.
Over five days of testimony, a TBI forensic scientist told jurors that blood on rocks at the home matched Kay Farley and that blood found on Wilburn’s Chevrolet Trailblazer and on a 12-gauge pump shotgun matched Marty Farley. A TBI arson investigator testified that the fire had two areas of origin and that he ruled out natural and electrical causes. A woman who stayed with Wilburn at an Alcoa motel that weekend testified that he told her he had killed someone and came back with blood on him, and jurors heard recordings she made of their conversations.
The defense. Wilburn did not testify, and his attorney, Rick Owens, called no witnesses. In police interviews played for the jury, Wilburn denied involvement, said he never left the motel that day and called his recorded remarks a joke. Owens told jurors the state’s case rested heavily on the woman who made the recordings and asked them to weigh whether their doubts were reasonable.
What comes next. Life without parole means Wilburn will not be eligible for release. The judge will impose sentences on the other 35 convictions on Jan. 7. Like any defendant convicted at trial in Tennessee, Wilburn can ask for a new trial and appeal to the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals.
The case was investigated by the Blount County Sheriff’s Office, led by Sgt. Isaac Staley, with the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation. The killings were among the deadliest residential fires in Blount County in recent years.
Sources:
WBIR, “Jury finds Johnny Ray Wilburn guilty, sentences him to life without parole for the murder of 3 people in Blount County,” Oct. 27, 2026 (verdict, sentence, victims, court records, testimony, closing arguments, Jan. 7 sentencing), https://www.wbir.com/article/news/crime/jury-begins-deliberation-trial-man-accused-killing-blount-co-family-setting-house-fire/51-c313477d-1c83-4bc0-a650-32b584962d15
WIVK, “Jury convicts Walland man in deadly Blount County fire that killed three,” Oct. 27, 2026 (38 of 39 counts, acquittal on animal abuse count, family quote), https://www.wivk.com/2026/10/27/jury-convicts-walland-man-in-deadly-blount-county-fire-that-killed-three/
Photo: Brian Stansberry, “Blount-county-tennessee-courthouse1.jpg,” Feb. 23, 2008, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/), cropped and color-adjusted, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Blount-county-tennessee-courthouse1.jpg
