News · Memphis
Memphis council took up a data center moratorium Tuesday; the long freeze failed on a 6-6 tie and a 135-day pause passed instead
MEMPHIS, Tenn. — The Memphis City Council voted Tuesday, Oct. 20, on whether to stop issuing permits for new data centers, two weeks after it postponed the question and a protest broke up its last meeting. The longer freeze, by then stretched to 18 months, failed on a 6-6 tie, and the council instead passed a 135-day pause on data center permitting sponsored by Councilman Jeff Warren and Councilwoman Rhonda Logan, CNN and Action News 5 reported. Daily Deskline’s full story on the vote has the details.
Ordinance 5982, sponsored by council members JB Smiley Jr., Jerri Green, Jana Swearengen-Washington and Michalyn Easter-Thomas, would have placed a temporary moratorium on accepting, processing, approving and issuing zoning, land-use, building and related infrastructure permits for data center developments in the city, according to the council’s Oct. 20 agenda. The original Smiley and Green proposal called for a 12-month pause, the Commercial Appeal reported. The measure was up for third and final reading at the council’s 4 p.m. Central meeting in the chambers at City Hall, 125 N. Main St.
Two competing approaches sat right beside it on the agenda. Councilman Philip Spinosa’s Ordinance 5985 would, in the agenda’s words, “replace a blanket data-center moratorium with source-neutral, tiered, and timed review,” with a water-planning standard, a recurring fiscal floor and required development agreements. The Commercial Appeal reported that Spinosa’s plan would put stricter review on data centers drawing 20 megawatts or more without halting construction. Councilman Jeff Warren’s Ordinance 5986 would ban routine evaporative and once-through cooling, require closed-loop water systems, prohibit major withdrawals of local water for cooling and phase in renewable and non-carbon electricity. Two more data center zoning amendments, Ordinances 5987 and 5988, were on the consent agenda for second reading.
On Oct. 6, the council voted 7-5 on Vice Chairman Chase Carlisle’s motion to hold the moratorium and the other data center measures, with Carlisle saying members needed more time to work through them. After the vote, opponents of data center growth yelled, chanted and used bullhorns, council members left the chamber, and the rest of the meeting was canceled after police and City Hall security cleared the room, according to Commercial Appeal, Daily Memphian and Action News 5 reports compiled by Memphis Report.
Mayor Paul Young signed an executive order Oct. 9 creating a 90-day expert review of possible guardrails covering land use and neighborhood protections, infrastructure, air quality, water and aquifer protection, energy and utility costs, and noise, with at least three community education sessions, the Memphis Flyer reported. “The executive order does not suspend, delay, restrict, or interfere with council action,” Young said.
The tax base is part of the debate. Young has put the amount SpaceXAI generated for the city and county this year at $54 million, Action News 5 reported, while also saying more protections are needed. At a council work session after the delay, council attorney Allan Wade raised potential legal trouble with a moratorium and said some of the proposals reached into areas outside the council’s control. “If we’re going to be talking about what to do, we need to stay in our lane, in my opinion,” Wade said, according to the Flyer.
Residents have pushed back on health and environmental grounds since SpaceXAI’s data centers went into Boxtown and Whitehaven more than a year ago, WREG reported. At a community forum in Binghampton this week, Shelby County Commissioner Henri E. Brooks described seeing what she took for barbecue smoke from a stadium and realizing it was coming from the generators. Supporters of the pause, including state Rep. Justin J. Pearson, say the city should study the effects on water, air and neighborhoods before more projects are permitted.
The issue has also reached the governor’s race. Republican U.S. Sen. Marsha Blackburn told WREG that if a data center comes in, “they need to tote the note, pay their own way, and not have it pushed off on the citizens,” and said the state could address noise and environmental provisions. Democrat Jerri Green, the council member who co-sponsored the moratorium, said regulations should be in place “before we move forward.”
Memphis is not the only Shelby County government weighing a pause. Millington approved a six-month data center moratorium earlier this month, as Daily Deskline reported.
Updated Oct. 21, 2026: The council rejected the longer data center moratorium on a 6-6 tie and passed a 135-day pause instead, so this story’s headline and opening now report the outcome. Sources: CNN and Action News 5.
Sources:
WREG, “City council to vote on data center moratorium Tuesday,” Oct. 18, 2026, https://wreg.com/news/city-council-to-vote-on-data-center-moratorium-tuesday/
Memphis City Council, “City Council Meeting Agenda, October 20, 2026,” https://memphistn.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Regular-Agenda-10.20.26.pdf
Memphis Report, “Protest shuts down Memphis council meeting after 7-5 vote delays data-center moratorium to Oct. 20,” Oct. 6, 2026, https://memphisreport.com/2026/10/06/memphis-city-council-data-center-moratorium-postponed-oct-20-2026/
Memphis Flyer, “Mayor Paul Young Signs Order for 90-Day Data Center Study,” https://www.memphisflyer.com/mayor-paul-young-signs-order-for-90-day-data-center-study/
Action News 5 (WMC), “‘I’m human’: Mayor Young addresses criticism, issues executive order for xAI guardrails after recent protests,” Oct. 9, 2026, https://www.actionnews5.com/2026/10/09/mayor-young-address-public-after-recent-data-center-debate/
CNN, “Memphis leaders reject contentious 18-month pause on new data center development,” Oct. 20, 2026, https://www.cnn.com/2026/10/20/us/memphis-council-data-center-vote
Action News 5 (WMC), “Memphians react to failed data center moratorium,” Oct. 21, 2026, https://www.actionnews5.com/2026/10/21/memphians-react-failed-data-center-moratorium/
Image: Thomas R Machnitzki, “Memphis City Hall Main St Memphis TN 10.jpg,” Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0), https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Memphis_City_Hall_Main_St_Memphis_TN_10.jpg
