News · Memphis
Memphis shuts Castalia Market and Save a Stop #2 as public nuisances after 229 police calls at one store, a homicide and gunfire at officers
MEMPHIS — Two Memphis convenience stores that police tied to a homicide, shootings, drug sales and illegal gambling were ordered closed Wednesday as public nuisances.
The Memphis Police Department’s Organized Crime Unit, working with the City of Memphis and the Shelby County District Attorney’s Office, closed Community Grocery, also known as Castalia Market, at 1701 Castalia St., and Save a Stop #2 at 2757 Kimball Ave., the department said in a Nov. 5 release. Both were declared public nuisances under Tennessee’s nuisance-abatement law, and closure orders were issued.
Castalia Market: Officers answered 229 calls for service at the store between Oct. 18, 2024, and Oct. 18, 2026, leading to 71 reports and 24 arrests, police said. By our math, that is a call about every three days for two years. The reported crimes included a homicide, armed robbery, aggravated assaults, narcotics violations and gun recoveries.
The owners got written notice under the nuisance law on April 29, police said, but the crime continued: armed threats against customers on May 6, a homicide inside the store on June 16, when two stolen guns were recovered, and an Oct. 5 aggravated assault involving an armed convicted felon.
Save a Stop #2: Police listed shootings at the Kimball Avenue store in January and May 2025, one of which critically injured a woman; two people arrested in June 2025 carrying guns fitted with illegal machine-gun conversion devices known as switches; a search warrant that seized four illegal gambling machines and cash; and drug cases that turned up a stolen gun. The owners got written notice on July 13, 2026.
Twelve days later, on July 25, officers seized cocaine, ecstasy, oxycodone, Xanax and marijuana in a felony drug investigation there. On Oct. 3 an employee was the victim of an armed aggravated assault, and on Oct. 9 a fleeing suspect fired several shots at officers in what police called an officer-involved shooting, with gunfire striking a nearby property.
“Despite prior notice and continued enforcement efforts, criminal activity persisted, creating serious safety concerns for the surrounding neighborhoods and businesses,” the department said.
Under the state nuisance statute, Tennessee Code Annotated Section 29-3-101, the district attorney brings a civil case with police, and a property the court declares a public nuisance may stay shut until the owner can assure the illegal activity will stop, according to the Shelby County Environmental Court, which hears the cases. Police did not say when either store might reopen or name the owners.
Sources:
Memphis Police Department, “MPD Announces Nuisance Closures of Castalia Market and Save A Stop #2” (Nov. 5, 2026; calls, reports, arrests, notice dates, incidents, quote), https://www.memphispolice.org/news/mpd-announces-nuisance-closures-of-castalia-market-and-save-a-stop-2/
Shelby County Environmental Court, “Cases” (how nuisance cases under TCA § 29-3-101 work), https://www.shelbycountyenvironmentalcourt.com/cases
WMC Action News 5, “2 Memphis convenience stores shut down due to repeated criminal activity” (Nov. 4, 2026; closures Wednesday), https://www.actionnews5.com/2026/11/04/2-memphis-convenience-stores-shut-down-due-repeated-criminal-activity/
Photo: Thomas R Machnitzki, “Memphis Skyline from Poplar Ave.jpg,” Sept. 19, 2010, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0, cropped and resized, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Memphis_Skyline_from_Poplar_Ave.jpg
