News · Nashville
Nashville must shrink its Metro Council from 40 seats to 20 after the Tennessee Supreme Court upholds the state law
NASHVILLE — Nashville’s 40-member Metro Council will have to shrink to no more than 20 members after the Tennessee Supreme Court on Monday upheld the 2023 state law that caps the size of metropolitan councils.
The court did not set a deadline. It sent the case, Metro v. Lee, back to the trial court for further proceedings, the Nashville Banner reported. The justices rejected Metro’s argument that the Tennessee Constitution’s “Exemption Clause” shields consolidated city-county governments from a cap, agreeing with the state that the clause covers only constitutional restrictions and does not stop the General Assembly from setting other limits.
House Majority Leader William Lamberth, R-Portland, who led the 2023 bill, called the ruling “a big win for small government and common sense.” The law, amended this year, also covers Tennessee’s two other metropolitan governments, but Nashville’s is the only one of the three with a legislative body of more than 20 members, the Banner noted.
Metro pushes back
Metro had won at the trial court but lost at the Court of Appeals before the high court took the case. “Nashville’s Council size was set by our community, and our charter should only be changed by our voters — not by the state legislature,” Mayor Freddie O’Connell said Monday.
Vice Mayor Angie Henderson called it “a somber day for democracy in Tennessee” in a joint statement with Charter Revision Committee Chair Clay Capp. They said the Council Office, the Metro Legal Department and the council will review the decision, and that the full council will be invited to a special Charter Revision Committee meeting next week.
What happens next
Charter amendments normally need voter approval, and the next scheduled election where voters could weigh in is in 2027, when council seats are on the ballot. But the state law also allows Metro to make the change by a simple majority vote of the council, the Banner reported. In September, O’Connell said it was hard to see any ruling this late changing the 2027 elections.
The council has had 40 members — 35 district seats and five at-large — since Metro government was formed in 1963. When the law passed in 2023, Metro officials looked at options that included 17 district seats and three at-large.
What it means for representation
Using the 715,000 population figure in Henderson’s statement, each of today’s 40 council members represents about 17,900 residents on average. At 20 members, that would be about 35,750 people per member. For comparison, Lamberth’s Sumner County, with less than a third of Davidson County’s population, has a 24-member county commission, the Banner noted.
Sources:
Nashville Banner, “Ruling means Nashville Metro Council size will shrink,” Nov. 2, 2026 (ruling, Exemption Clause, remand, Lamberth and O’Connell quotes, case history, 2027 timing, simple-majority option, 1963 structure, 17+3 scenario, Sumner County), https://nashvillebanner.com/2026/11/02/nashville-metro-council-size-ruling/
Metro Nashville Council Office, “Vice Mayor Angie Henderson and Charter Revision Committee Chair Clay Capp Issue Joint Statement Following Tennessee Supreme Court Decision,” Nov. 2, 2026 (Metro v. Lee, 2023 law amended 2026, statement quotes, special committee meeting, 715,000 population), https://www.nashville.gov/departments/council/news/vice-mayor-angie-henderson-and-charter-revision-committee-chair-clay-capp-issue-joint-statement-following-tennessee-supreme-court-decision
Photo: Warren LeMay, “Davidson County Courthouse and Nashville City Hall, Public Square, Nashville, TN (54385061456).jpg,” Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/), cropped and resized; derivative shared under the same license, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Davidson_County_Courthouse_and_Nashville_City_Hall,_Public_Square,_Nashville,_TN_(54385061456).jpg
