News · Smyrna
Losing bidder sues again over the $9.2 billion I-24 toll lanes, saying TDOT let the winner rework its $24.8 billion offer
NASHVILLE — A road-building group that lost the competition for Tennessee’s planned toll lanes on Interstate 24 has filed a second lawsuit against the state, arguing the Tennessee Department of Transportation let the winning team change the terms of its record-setting offer after the bids were opened.
The 24 Choice Lanes Partners consortium filed the petition last week in Davidson County Chancery Court, Axios Nashville and the Tennessee Lookout reported. It asks a judge to review TDOT’s award to DriveTN, a group led by the Spanish company Ferrovial, and to block further action under the contract while the court decides whether the state let DriveTN rework its financial terms.
The project. The I-24 Choice Lanes would add optional toll lanes along 26 miles of the interstate between southeast Nashville and Murfreesboro, through La Vergne and Smyrna. Under the deal, DriveTN would finance, build, operate and maintain the lanes. It won by offering payments to the state valued at $24.8 billion for the right to run them for 50 years, more than three times the next-highest offer of $7.4 billion, Axios reported. TDOT picked DriveTN on Aug. 19 and signed the contract Sept. 30.
The complaint. The losing consortium says DriveTN’s winning bid promised to pay the state within seven years of closing, and that the state is now letting it “reduce, defer or stretch those payments far beyond the construction period,” according to the filing quoted by the Lookout. It also says TDOT made every bidder’s financial proposal public at a meeting and then let DriveTN negotiate its final terms knowing where the others stood, while rival bidders were held to offers they had made “blind.”
The lawsuit points to financial reporting that DriveTN was negotiating to delay some payments, but it does not show that TDOT agreed to any change, Axios noted. The payment terms in the signed contract have not been made public.
The state’s side. TDOT declined to comment on the litigation, Axios reported. Before the suit was filed, a department spokesperson told the Lookout that the 2023 Transportation Modernization Act, which allowed the public-private toll lane project, has no bid-protest provision for such deals. The same law also put $3.3 billion from the state’s general fund toward road projects.
What’s next. The consortium is also suing TDOT in a separate public records case to get the final contract and related financial documents. TDOT has said it will hand over a redacted copy of the signed agreement by Oct. 30, according to the latest filing in that case. Rutherford County’s WGNS Radio listed the new lawsuit among the top local stories Monday.
Analysis: This is Tennessee’s first public-private toll-lane deal, and what it is worth to the state comes down to the size and timing of DriveTN’s payments. Until those terms are public, commuters from Smyrna and Murfreesboro, and the taxpayers who fund the state’s road budget, have no way to judge whether the state got the deal it advertised.
All times are Central.
Sources:
Axios Nashville, “Losing bidder challenges TDOT’s $9.2B I-24 toll-lane deal,” Oct. 15, 2026, https://www.axios.com/local/nashville/2026/10/15/tennessee-toll-lane-contract-lawsuit
Tennessee Lookout, “Losing bidder claims state changed terms on I-24 toll lane project,” Oct. 16, 2026, https://tennesseelookout.com/2026/10/16/losing-bidder-claims-state-changed-terms-on-i-24-toll-lane-project/
WGNS Radio, “Rutherford County Jail Battle, Early Voting Surge & I-24 Choice Lanes Lawsuit,” Oct. 19, 2026, https://www.wgnsradio.com/article/101642/rutherford-county-jail-battle-early-voting-surge-i-24-choice-lanes-lawsuit-oct-19-2026
Image: ElToAn123, “TDOT HELP truck 7329 in Nashville, 2021.jpg,” Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped and resized, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:TDOT_HELP_truck_7329_in_Nashville,_2021.jpg
