News · Knoxville
Federal judge in Knoxville rules Tennessee can’t bar a Christian charter school for being religious
KNOXVILLE — A federal judge in Knoxville has ruled that Tennessee cannot keep a Christian group out of its charter school program because the school it wants to open would be religious, and he permanently barred the Knox County Board of Education from enforcing the state law that requires charter schools to be nonreligious.
U.S. District Judge Charles E. Atchley Jr. of the Eastern District of Tennessee signed the memorandum opinion and order on Friday, Nov. 6, in The Wilberforce Academy of Knoxville v. Knox County Board of Education. The order bars the board from enforcing Tenn. Code Ann. § 49-13-111(a)(2), the line in the state’s Public Charter Schools Act that says a charter school must operate as a “public, nonsectarian, nonreligious” school. The order says a separate judgment will be entered.
“The First Amendment does not permit the State to require an organization to abandon its religious beliefs or practices as the price of participating in a public benefit program,” Atchley wrote.
What the judge decided
Atchley found that the chance to apply for and contract with an authorizer to run a charter school is a generally available public benefit, and that the nonsectarian rule shuts out otherwise eligible groups because of their religious exercise. He relied heavily on the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in Carson v. Makin, which struck down Maine’s ban on tuition aid for religious schools.
The judge also rejected arguments that a group running a charter school becomes part of the government. Tennessee charter schools are run by private nonprofit sponsors that choose their own boards, he wrote, and heavy state regulation and public funding do not turn them into government entities. He noted that his ruling covers federal law only and does not decide whether charter schools are public schools under Tennessee law.
The order does not approve a school. It stops the Knox County board from using the nonsectarian rule against Wilberforce’s application.
How the case got here
According to the opinion, Wilberforce incorporated on Nov. 21, 2025, sent the board a letter of intent on Nov. 25 to open a Christian charter school for the 2027–28 school year, and sued on Nov. 30. The group paid a consultant $140,000 and finished a 279-page application, the opinion says, but did not file it before the Feb. 1, 2026, deadline because the state form required it to affirm the school would be nonsectarian and nonreligious. Atchley found that applying would have been futile.
The legislature changed the law in 2026 to let religious nonprofits sponsor charter schools, but left the requirement that the schools themselves be nonreligious. That remaining requirement is what the court blocked.
The Knox County board did not take a position on whether the law was constitutional, and the state did not intervene, the opinion says. Two groups joined the case to defend it: Knox County taxpayers whose children attend traditional public schools, and parents of charter school students in Memphis, Nashville and Chattanooga.
Reaction
“This victory is bigger than a courtroom ruling,” Wilberforce executive director Zach Wishart told WBIR-TV. “It advances educational freedom and opens the door for more children, regardless of their family’s financial circumstances, to access a tuition-free, Christ-centered education.”
The National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, which opposes religious charter schools, said in a Nov. 6 statement that it was “deeply disappointed by a ruling that threatens the public foundation of charter schools and the accountability that comes with it.”
The ruling is from a single federal district court. It could be appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.
Sources:
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee, The Wilberforce Academy of Knoxville v. Knox County Board of Education, No. 3:25-cv-584, Doc. 156, Memorandum Opinion and Order, Nov. 6, 2026 (via Justia), https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/tennessee/tnedce/3:2025cv00584/122190/156/
WBIR-TV, “U.S. District Court allows Christian organization to establish charter school in Knoxville,” Nov. 9, 2026 (Wishart quote), https://www.wbir.com/article/news/education/us-district-court-allows-christian-organization-establish-charter-school-knoxville/51-114e3546-8f90-4a26-af98-690dfc1332ff
National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, “Tennessee Ruling and Oklahoma Appeal Threaten the Public Foundation of Charter Schools Nationwide,” Nov. 6, 2026, https://publiccharters.org/news/tennessee-ruling-and-oklahoma-appeal-threaten-the-public-foundation-of-charter-schools-nationwide/
Photo: Antony-22, “Howard H. Baker, Jr. U.S. Courthouse 2025a.jpg,” Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped, color-adjusted and resized; derivative shared under the same license, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Howard_H._Baker,_Jr._U.S._Courthouse_2025a.jpg
