News
Daily Deskline

Where to go, towns to see, and the people you will find from the Mississippi to the Smokies.


News · Murfreesboro

Rutherford County keeps eminent domain on the table for its new jail site while it tries to buy the old fairgrounds

The multistory brick and glass Rutherford County Judicial Center in Murfreesboro under a clear blue sky, with a white columned entrance and a brick sign reading Rutherford County Judicial Center
The Rutherford County Judicial Center in Murfreesboro in a file photo. It is not the proposed jail site. Photo: Lengau via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0), cropped and color-adjusted.

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. — Rutherford County is keeping its power to take the old county fairgrounds by eminent domain for a new jail, but commissioners say they would rather pay the owners a fair price and avoid a court fight. At their Thursday night meeting, commissioners declined to rescind a July condemnation resolution for the South Church Street property and agreed to go back to the owners and negotiate a higher price, WKRN-TV reported.

“If we vote not to rescind, then that gives us leverage to go to the table to negotiate a fair price for all concerned, get a contract signed, and then ultimately we will not have to proceed with this,” District 20 Commissioner Trey Gooch said, according to WKRN. “The Church Street property is the best property for the long term — for long-term growth and for long-term cost. If we vote to rescind tonight, the best option’s off the table, and you know it.”

“I want us to end up giving the owner a just and fair amount of money to purchase their property,” District 21 Commissioner Laura Clark said.

Not everyone was comfortable. “Even if we decide not to rescind, it’s still taking somebody’s property. Period,” District 1 Commissioner Hope Oliver said. “Whether you feel like it’s at a lower price, higher price, whatever, you’re still taking somebody’s property, and I’m just challenged with that.”

The county says it needs the space. The Rutherford County Adult Detention Center holds more than 1,100 inmates in a building designed for fewer than 500, WKRN reported, and commissioners voted unanimously in February to move forward with a new jail that the station put at $365 million. The Daily News Journal has put the full jail and sheriff’s office campus at $375 million. Commissioners told WKRN the new jail would not open until around 2031.

The site is about 52.67 acres near Rutherford Boulevard and South Church Street, next to the county’s Correctional Work Center and near its juvenile justice facilities, which commissioners say could cut transportation, medical and food service costs, The Murfreesboro Pulse reported. The commission approved the condemnation resolution in a split vote on July 16. It set the land’s estimated value at $14 million to $18 million and capped a voluntary purchase at $18 million, according to the Pulse.

The owners, Joni Werthan and PWU Properties, have asked the county to drop the condemnation. Their attorney, Joshua Denton, has said the county offered about $23.8 million for the land during an earlier public sale and was not chosen, and that the property went under contract with another buyer for $38 million on June 5, the Pulse and the Daily News Journal reported. In a July letter, Denton argued that the county would also give up more than $1 million a year in property taxes the developed land could generate.

There are other open questions. In a July 23 letter, Murfreesboro City Manager Darren Gore said the project would need a sewer variance, because the site has sewer capacity equal to about 208 single-family homes while the existing jail discharges the equivalent of 278, according to the Pulse.

Meanwhile, county taxpayers are already covering part of the bill for inmates sentenced to state custody. On WGNS Radio on Friday, Commissioner Rick Hall, who chairs the Public Safety Committee, said it costs the county about $83 a day to hold each state-ready inmate while the state pays back only about $46, leaving a roughly $6 million yearly gap that local taxpayers cover.

WKRN reported that a hearing on the property is set to go before a judge early next year. The commission’s Steering, Legislative and Governmental Committee, which carried Thursday’s jail condemnation report, meets next on Nov. 2, and the full commission meets again Nov. 12, according to the meeting agenda.

Sources:
WKRN-TV, “Plans for new jail turn into battle over land in Rutherford County,” Oct. 16, 2026, https://www.wkrn.com/news/local-news/murfreesboro/plans-for-new-jail-turn-into-battle-over-land-in-rutherford-county/
Ashlen Jones, “Rutherford County Considers New Jail as Property Owners at Proposed Site Oppose Eminent Domain,” The Murfreesboro Pulse, September 2026, https://boropulse.com/2026/09/rutherford-county-considers-new-jail-as-property-owners-at-proposed-site-oppose-eminent-domain/
Scott Broden, “Rutherford County jail project could cost $1M in lost taxes,” The Daily News Journal, Aug. 4, 2026, https://www.dnj.com/story/news/2026/08/04/condemnation-rutherford-county-jail-project-tax-dollars/91115609007/
WGNS Radio, “Landlocked Cruise Ships & $38M Property Battles: What’s Happening in Rutherford County?” Oct. 16, 2026, https://www.wgnsradio.com/article/101613/landlocked-cruise-ships-38m-property-battles-whats-happening-in-rutherford-county
Rutherford County Board of Commissioners, meeting agenda, Oct. 15, 2026, https://rutherfordcountytn.gov/vertical/sites/%7B0DE57B3C-95FA-46CF-BF78-CE4E5703EB9C%7D/uploads/Commission_Agenda_10.15.26.pdf
Image: Lengau, “Rutherford County Judicial Building,” Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0), https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rutherford_County_Judicial_Building.jpg

Murfreesboro

More from Murfreesboro

All Murfreesboro news