News · Upper Cumberland
Two Overton County men sentenced for cutting down and selling a 55-foot black walnut tree from Standing Stone State Forest
OVERTON COUNTY — Two Overton County men have been sentenced for cutting down a black walnut tree in Standing Stone State Forest and selling it to a sawmill, the Tennessee Department of Agriculture said Tuesday. The tree stood about 55 feet tall and measured 30 inches across.
The case was worked by the department’s Agricultural Crime Unit, a small team most Tennesseans have never heard of that handles theft and fraud involving farms, timber and livestock.
The sentences. Derek Smith pleaded guilty Sept. 14 to theft of property valued at more than $1,000, a Class E felony. He received two years of probation through the Tennessee Department of Correction and must pay $2,050 in restitution and a $1,000 fine, the department said.
Marvin Hall pleaded guilty Oct. 5 to the same charge. He received a two-year sentence, with six months to serve and 18 months on probation, plus $2,050 in restitution and a $3,000 fine. Both men are banned from Standing Stone State Forest and Standing Stone State Park.
How it was cracked. The investigation began May 21, when the department’s Forestry Division reported the walnut had been cut down. At first the tree looked as if it had fallen in a direction that would make it hard to haul out of the woods. On June 5, investigators learned it was gone.
Three days later, a regional sawmill owner called ACU Special Agent Christopher Magee and said he had bought a black walnut log from Hall on the day it was taken. The mill owner identified both Hall and Smith, according to the department. Agents worked with Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation park rangers to gather evidence and served search warrants. The case went to a grand jury on Aug. 3, and it indicted both men.
“Protecting Tennessee’s natural resources takes cooperation and follow-through,” Agriculture Commissioner Andy Holt said in the release. “This case shows the value of our Agricultural Crime Unit working alongside our Forestry Division and law enforcement partners to investigate crimes and pursue accountability.”
Why a single tree matters. Black walnut is among the most valuable hardwoods in Tennessee forests, prized for furniture, gunstocks and veneer, which is why a single big tree can draw thieves. Standing Stone State Forest in Overton County is public land managed by the department’s Forestry Division. A tree cut there is taken from every taxpayer, and in this case the honest buyer at the mill is the reason it was traced.
A busy unit. The ACU investigated 49 cases in October alone, the department said. In July, it closed a separate case in Henry County that ended with restitution for a landowner whose white oaks were cut and removed.
How to report. Anyone who sees signs of timber theft, or a sawmill or log buyer offered suspicious wood, can call the ACU at 844-AG-CRIME (844-242-7463) or email Agriculture.Crime@tn.gov. All dates are 2026; times are Central.
Sources:
Tennessee Department of Agriculture, “Two Men Sentenced for Stealing Black Walnut Tree from State Forest,” Oct. 27, 2026 (pleas, sentences, bans, timeline, sawmill tip, Holt quote, 49 cases in October, contact), https://www.tn.gov/agriculture/news/2026/10/27/two-men-sentenced-for-stealing-black-walnut-tree-from-state-forest.html
Herald-Citizen, “Overton County men sentenced for tree theft,” Oct. 27, 2026, https://www.herald-citizen.com/news/crime/overton-county-men-sentenced-for-tree-theft/article_4b8befbb-1f88-553b-be64-335ce2dd7810.html
Tennessee Department of Agriculture, “Timber Theft Case Ends with Restitution for Henry County Landowner,” July 9, 2026, https://www.tn.gov/agriculture/news/2026/7/9/timber-theft-case-ends-with-restitution-for-henry-county-landowner.html
Photo: Brian Stansberry, “Standing-stone-state-forest-tn1.jpg,” May 31, 2008, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/), cropped and color-adjusted, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Standing-stone-state-forest-tn1.jpg
